Batman: Detective Comics: The Joker War by Peter J. Tomasi

Title: Batman: Detective Comics.
Story-arc: The Joker War.
Volume: 5.
Writer(s): Peter J. Tomasi.
Penciller(s): Brad Walker, Kenneth Rocafort, Sumit Kumar & Eduardo Risso.
Inker(s): Andrew Hennessey & Norm Rapmund.
Colourist(s): Brad Anderson, Daniel Brown, Romulo Fajardo Jr. & Eduardo Risso.
Letterer(s): Rob Leigh & Tom Napolitano.
Publisher: DC Comics.
Format: Single Issues.
Release Date: March 23 2021.
Pages: 256.
Genre(s): Comics, Science-Fiction.
ISBN13: 9781779509222.
My Overall Rating:

Rating: 2.5 out of 5.

Previously in the Batman: Detective Comics (2016―) series:
Batman: Detective Comics (Vol. 1): Mythology by Peter J. Tomasi.
Batman: Detective Comics (Vol. 2): Arkham Knight by Peter J. Tomasi.
Batman: Detective Comics (Vol. 3): Greetings From Gotham by Peter J. Tomasi
Batman: Detective Comics (Vol. 4): Cold Vengeance by Peter J. Tomasi.


Writer Peter J. Tomasi has been continuously dishing out some of the most forgettable Batman stories yet ever since he’s been put on the Detective Comics series following writer James Tynion IV’s departure from this comic book run. With the past story arcs, he has shown very little promise for the future of this series and his material continues to be marked by a resolute absence of interest and passion for the Dark Knight’s adventures. This time around, forced once again by ongoing DC events, he presents fans with a story arc set prior to the canonical Batman run’s Joker War story arc. Drawing upon the excitement revolving around that event, he offers us an inconsequential tale that features elements from the New 52 run while placing an old-friend-turned-evil at the center of his story.

What is Batman: Detective Comics: The Joker War about? Set after the tragic events that took Alfred Pennyworth from Bruce Wayne’s life, the story explores the sudden return of Two-Face who now looks to gain leverage on his competitors and take back the reins on Gotham City following the wake of “City of Bane”. Bound by duality within his personality, Harvey Dent continues to show a lack of control that forces Batman to take extreme measures to try and steer him back on the right path. Unfortunately, there is more to Two-Face’s plans than the gruesome crimes he’s been committing as the Joker seems to have had a hand in Harvey Dent’s recent uprising. This volume collects Batman: Pennyworth R.I.P., Detective Comics #1020-1026, an 8-page story from Detective Comics #1027, and Detective Comics Annual #3.

“In the midst of chaos there is always opportunity.”

— Peter J. Tomasi

When will this madness end? Luckily for this volume, it contained an 8-page story from Detective Comics #1027 that led me to read the entire epic-size issue that celebrated the 1000-issue anniversary of the Dark Knight, containing various stories by countless famous writers and artists that showcased the best of Batman’s character and adventures. If I hadn’t had that mouthwash, I would’ve had a tough time being positive about the main story at the heart of this volume. In fact, what writer Peter J. Tomasi offers fans turns out as unmemorable as stories could get, especially when the desperation to come up with something original rests upon the use of content from the New 52 Batman and Detective Comics run. It also doesn’t help when the story gets quite ridiculous with Two-Face’s cult and derivative split-personality issues. Even when the story shoehorns Joker’s involvement, building up the Joker War event, the story resorts to bombastic action sequences to try and save its own hide.

Although the whole volume does feel like a filler, showcasing the writer’s disinterest to try and go above and beyond what is expected of Batman’s adventures, some positive thoughts can be squeezed out of penciler Brad Walker’s artwork. Responsible for most of the story arc’s art, he presents fans with a very impactful and vivid take on the Caped Crusader’s adventure through imposing character designs and huge panels. Many pages utilize a zoomed-in approach to accentuate the tension and drama, sometimes overly, to capture the sense of danger and the shortness of time that comes with this forgettable narrative. The colouring is also without reproach, managing to remain loyal to fans’ conception of Batman’s universe. Unfortunately, most of the appreciation derives from the non-central story arcs collected in this volume that capture a grimmer and much more emotional take on the Dark Knight’s current state prior to the Joker War event. Writer Peter J. Tomasi really needs to find his groove soon.

Batman: Detective Comics: The Joker War is an uninspiring tale bringing to light Two Face’s conflicted nature and Joker’s involvement in the grand scheme of things, mostly saved by the adjacent issues collected in this volume.




20 thoughts on “Batman: Detective Comics: The Joker War by Peter J. Tomasi

  1. Umm thanks but no 😉. I’m so glad you’re here to read these mediocre comics for us, Lashaan, and deliver your thoughtful, precise reviews to us! This way we can only read your reviews instead of the comics and commiserate with you! 😁

    Liked by 2 people

      1. Hahahaha as much as I’d like to endure everything Superman-related, there is only enough time (and room) for one superhero-fanaticism. 😛 I’m still trying to follow what’s going on with him nowadays though. I honestly can’t tell which of the two has had it rougher.

        Liked by 1 person

  2. Man, I know how much you like Batman so I always hate seeing you slog through stories that completely disappoint you (though I’m sure not nearly as much as you hate it!).

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Dang it. I hate this didn’t work better for you. Thanks for sharing Lashaan. I bet you got stacks of comic books all over, huh? Ever think about getting rid of any of them or are you collecting for keeps?

    Liked by 1 person

    1. At this point, I’m not too shocked that it isn’t getting any better. I’m just hoping things will get better sooner rather than later!

      I haven’t yet contemplated the idea of getting rid of anything. I’m mostly building my collection as a heritage. I’m sure in the near future I’ll get rid of some comics that I know aren’t worth keeping around though.

      Liked by 1 person

    1. Hahah I saw that one of the recent issues had SOME Jorge Jimenez artwork but it doesn’t seem like he’s sticking around. 😦 With the next story arc titled “Joker War Aftermath” (at least for now), I’m not toooooooo hopeful that it’ll be any different than what this had to offer but if you those Joker War tie-in you speak of are those collected in the next volume, I’ll remain optimistic. I just want to see Peter J. Tomasi do a story arc without being too affected by the ongoing Batman run. He seems to need more… space… to give us something good.

      Liked by 1 person

  4. Do you feel more annoyed when you get a disappointing Batman piece (since you have a strong affinity to Batman) than anything else? Do you feel like this great character deserves more?

    (Side note: Your fist sentence seems incomplete.)

    Liked by 1 person

    1. In my earlier comic book reading days, yes. But once I understood the market and the character’s history, I knew, for a while now, that there are WAY more stories featuring top-tier heroes than other heroes and it is inevitable that some writers/artists give us mediocre, boring stories. Since then, it has become my duty to go through all of them (probably not ALL of them) to find the good ones and enjoy the heck out of those. 😀

      Thanks, I think I fixed it now, or maybe I’m making some kind of French-to-English syntax mistake hahah

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s